Re: [gentoo-project] Should Council members be pillars of the community?

[Rich Freeman <rich0@gentoo.org>]

On Fri, Jun 26, 2020 at 10:57 AM Andreas K. Huettel
<dilfridge@gentoo.org> wrote:
>
> > Tell us why you are the
> > reporter of most ComRel bugs in last 3 years and are even subject of
> > most bugs filed by others.
>
> Err... how did you arrive at that?
>
> I'm in council and not in comrel anymore, and I haven't seen any kind of
> statistics (nor any bugs since my comrel access has been removed long ago).
>

Frankly, if statistics like this do exist they shouldn't be the
subject of public discussion on lists.

An anonymous histogram on #of complaints for any dev might be
interesting.  (ie 5 unnamed devs had 3 complaints, 1 dev had 14, etc).

However, unless we shift to a model where comrel complaints are public
we shouldn't have people divulging information about how many
complaints (qualitatively or quantitatively) any particular dev has
filed or been the subject of.  Nobody should even know that somebody
has been the subject of a complaint.

Everybody already sees how most devs conduct themselves in public as
it is, they can judge for themselves if they are concerned with this.
If somebody has been a menace in private comrel should be dealing with
that outside the court of public opinion.

-- 
Rich