[gentoo-dev] x86 arch testing: please use -mfpmath=sse

["Michał Górny" <mgorny@gentoo.org>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1634 bytes --]

Hello,

TL;DR: when arch testing for x86, please use `-mfpmath=sse` (this may
require raising `-march=` to `pentium4` or newer, or adding `-msse2`.


The x86 architecture historically supports two floating-precision
arithmetic modes: using the 387 coprocessor, and using the SSE
instruction set.  The compilers default to using the former when
compiling for 32-bit x86, and the latter for amd64.

The problem with 387 arithmetic is that it uses nonstandard 80-bit
registers (vs 64-bit doubles).  While technically this means that it
achieves better precision, it often means that the same computations
yield different rounding results.  As a result, test built against amd64
fail with 387-based arithmetic.

While technically these tests are broken in the first place for doing
exact matching on floating-point arithmetic results, getting everything
fixed is a major issue.  These problems are quite unlikely to affect
real use cases.  On top of that, many upstreams don't care about 32-bit
systems much, and bothering them with avoidable test failures reduces
our chances of having real problems solved.

Therefore, I would like to ask arch testers not to test with 387
floating-point arithmetic anymore.  We have already switched amd64
multilib to use `-mfpmath=sse` for 32-bit multilib, and we are planning
to provide x86 profiles with SSE2 baseline as well.

Note that in order for `-mfpmath=sse` to be fully effectively, the code
must be compiled with SSE2 support.  This could be achieved by using `-
march=pentium4` or higher, or adding `-msse2`.

TIA.

-- 
Best regards,
Michał Górny


[-- Attachment #2: This is a digitally signed message part --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 512 bytes --]