From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: Received: from lists.gentoo.org (pigeon.gentoo.org [208.92.234.80]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA384 (256/256 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by finch.gentoo.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 5FEB5138239 for ; Fri, 1 Nov 2019 19:59:48 +0000 (UTC) Received: from pigeon.gentoo.org (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by pigeon.gentoo.org (Postfix) with SMTP id 5F85DE0833; Fri, 1 Nov 2019 19:59:44 +0000 (UTC) Received: from mout.kundenserver.de (mout.kundenserver.de [212.227.126.135]) (using TLSv1.2 with cipher ECDHE-RSA-AES128-GCM-SHA256 (128/128 bits)) (No client certificate requested) by pigeon.gentoo.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id B523CE0817 for ; Fri, 1 Nov 2019 19:59:43 +0000 (UTC) Received: from [192.168.6.147] ([212.159.46.162]) by mrelayeu.kundenserver.de (mreue011 [213.165.67.99]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MxV4T-1i2e9M0BZp-00xvQm for ; Fri, 01 Nov 2019 20:59:41 +0100 From: Michael 'veremitz' Everitt Subject: [gentoo-dev] RFC: Require full $P not just $PN on stable/keyword commit messages To: gentoo-dev Openpgp: preference=signencrypt Autocrypt: addr=gentoo@veremit.xyz; keydata= xsFNBFYW4iYBEACe6tybDDxhSUbyakb9YmxLWqm99vCpHTdSPTpZnlsLqD9bufySCSUdly+Q op5P0Kef4wzpEfrpGCf4UPBWlOdjvz5aOapltlXoSXjVbZXhnKuR1tLNiwJyTYLlADeI5T3u vHN58gvxfKzJa8wTwr2uzqS4DynnKaRin8YETlVWlchIufXAgdxAgImbhB+T67z7E1qZbreI IOl6jWcA/FQ7qQKEGSXC+b6XCDedFXutAwfVa8/EvAJ/SOtft2XVFs5GCp2wcQi0qyAdUzvM ADKWcka2NxGpobh1gVMuypr1G4e+NX0dlNeYi61UpFvAeg4xremkxtkIvGoGlKLBwWO4bF9D TIufW+Gbjdg1puyYUVZ3QgnlJ4hjj2tQvgJttxEZRWnblMA6q0LFjMI6o3vcqi/yN6WWgpnB DQZ3S2WXcpejrvX7zz4Q/Tz3Mv1O7rfB9c3cb1CxQhn/7jTQnWHiOMbfFd9gZr+KJSt0EhqU yCVhxWy3eZL8+vwJFg9aGLN6/eXwVpDcLRBdQ9cFewGYW3WU/OhaGmpoTbqUn/m90lym4XcQ HTEWtwbjZZHjeR2h4k5VAcgTYxLgtLkVX7wSuXpH2OX1jhlbiwdqBL5gM4EfPU/jxZxtUCkF NCC1qgTkRXjICbPA5Np9+J0Vl37Cuqw9n2U14ig7cJ4hI5098QARAQABzSdNaWNoYWVsIEog RXZlcml0dCA8bS5qLmV2ZXJpdHRAaWVlLm9yZz7CwYAEEwEIACoCGwMFCwkIBwMFFQoJCAsF FgIDAQACHgECF4ACGQEFAlxfXjYFCQoK4xAACgkQTDAzT5PCI3G/Xg//dvyjd9BeeTchLweU VUV/M7CDwssmWfpTXHBRjRm7CpQ5cisEWtzxxBvtnhaIsqNgySYKfZZmt22j3FdfB9BVcuBp 5fXnAnrz23PhVO8m5AbzJbBJbUVayi7E5b+v8nBvNDuRW931G5DwhGRqwe44RM32CzGyG1aj pbyMcLavbpJadn3fx7UfRjecrzI8GUaWDme7eKFiPik6xK1zKWZzSZGjz9kOT73l9ZwsETub G/6GRryOwSmhJCtUe+LqWNRjpfXQLnaGkbopGwIkP5G7nL/yIi8aCricyLHy0inHKjOz9qBr ytw0A+vCbofDMLHIe9xDOj1QOXl0qMvai7wVgV9947i7auv3/GA5J89tqleDf+bW2ROj9m0k OzDiOM5hG7ZAhBdbNkjmLo9IcqF4WfkGKfQ0El1FJFXP1lfo6s9Gf+dLhiRpUyGN0CxdZBc7 4+wkKmLaabGM7Ekgzum3sVQFg6G6b4C06Ylq/EnyO9DBDP/cYg7uJfnZHUnNoq81jiHe4GGE 1Q2YZxeT5l7DCataU1Fdt+tmKMHaIyiQGldAjeDYzhxxvCJr9AGZyu0g/JfcJhE6w2AlDs+z UW7vJPJs/AJEHZ7Eavnev+3Iu/tTxt1gfVAu0JCRH9xhiGnItEk9AGc5NPOC8/9W5xuZClHs XwJ+olbaMGFfQ5dbnS7OwU0EVhbiJgEQAMactX37YQEVejQ0IM+Jhk0mpqV3SR/O8CkaibX4 JlGqg/N0jg42W+nqCe2jeDshP096x64Yublz+4ou79kFcSbLid/kp/E6P5k0LW6kTRvd2hdj v73cGXKbRZ7UiESXsj4od+yMZ4izbKD9l1wa7LVtr87eO58hYQT+xFzc3cLXCwbDGB0P2IfG 3dq2Wim+LSzLJyAuxaatUD8oprm+gOEEdu9m0nC2UzECGc9z0XJQi01/isIqVLWP40WapJoj /UnDjrohhayqgzqELtE8UIrkBNIbMS3LKFhLLme47oGuV7U3V+vGNDJdOc4oro95bYyEgSq3 Wkn6wJG9Tg+8b87S2aWHJWNpjTgpCnB5B5WznfmeKZn5NZF9eJbUnkZKIuqvLXHzJCdp/FfS LaPzUsPIzeNqnZ6d/IfWwzq/ZbbxsW9ppII7Rn3rh350aCEOCzUzZ0NVmW/15eFFWRNrwSlz zFd97eohcFtsElYXoZmIdY7ax4/iWwmnfLlE85ueusABEQ5iL218khJUvUBdLpWnVQPk8zNV R6RoZAU7Kz3k3n6nbDWu0W0PWS1f5rwwA+N61ys1sl4wVix9VJ/zjxuq8kf0FrUmyuWOH+bO DBIOUAS9xmhEjSbr2t+SLPIIIacLwYvmWxX+cCukvAB4kkXHeoM6yazC816xmYxgbYkDABEB AAHCwWUEGAEIAA8CGwwFAl1svsMFCQsYQ50ACgkQTDAzT5PCI3F7vQ//eWE40BWkSKtxxmuV Q4ammFQIg3zu36VLjl+UGcWe8+sU4SwlgaQqwsW9uW3Q5qQhZUn/tMIm55gmUG8B+xfw+bWb l8PE6HF/4xemeAE+zeDlZCLHHKMdTMbHPBn5bW4Nqk7ZU2gHruXuPFQdZbgbKLqw5oRhSsA/ w2QyrpE5CzA3n+UQ8hGPcXjQ84C69mPiGVDAOScC5mxS5AAllFRy36QvJCFIIfxoZT9fbE2E J2huDIi6KWhZ2AHBKpMVtnLzkbid7EvJpx+ba6JGWZgzpTh0fnFBieyGpXbVWLD38kFzO68z Ob0t2It07M46bGj0SgYZ9NfXb+Y6etdDNqf49iASuTWnPajlR6EqXL+I+E9H3rGdLr9g3LBy MMlDRK+y+bvpZm5U0C3yneYHGZd6CxlGv9sTOLKhkEVtH6yGuQYGozZEp5f7rBR5E8sEDYVi hoRg102BOKFiLfkqMxrQVKiXwQ1zHEFYCtQK8GTN1u9J19y2PyXhSAWj9Kvo5B+SiLo4dru1 KorT39UxI3uoZ09uHEDPog+sbmda3aPpciw2b/GsgKy1jUjQIrGYIUDFtLmPdid+oeEXwiOn Vh1peikWIY3br2aDr0Nn5O0WiRWCnOi0p9CJzBv5HT5JFsK9dnP4LfdsF7kQcL6mHrhyvLdx TeBHZp8GTtWjBiR+Phk= Message-ID: <55b42dc1-cbfd-8fa0-8bfd-433e7c92a21f@veremit.xyz> Date: Fri, 1 Nov 2019 19:59:35 +0000 User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.9.1 Precedence: bulk List-Post: List-Help: List-Unsubscribe: List-Subscribe: List-Id: Gentoo Linux mail X-BeenThere: gentoo-dev@lists.gentoo.org Reply-to: gentoo-dev@lists.gentoo.org X-Auto-Response-Suppress: DR, RN, NRN, OOF, AutoReply MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha256; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="lwrnfQ7Ej7W9XJmwC4l8b0XKYT5rpxAbN" X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:By0ZlVTIHHp+HSirKUrk/fzToQ9AvLjLGqS8KrYAc6lBXrA/lFm 09IW5nxuWjbvjt0PLO6Sh0fw941GlcfYSArRqcL8jWxaKwXFtcZTm1pz+eXuu9COO2rIaSP MQH2RiBOMxd+SMD4hMawUl543N7hWXgPN/Av+DUeA/rPI3qNHLAYVdU+9v/Bdm0P3Bfkyap kVuGdDoSdYSwlCNmlzJaA== X-Spam-Flag: NO X-UI-Out-Filterresults: notjunk:1;V03:K0:lYlI7G8yDtE=:bts3WWYrtDE27xffTD34Y2 t8WEGwE7nSnd4Rh28jO9VmAX0+gMlwCEvpWFAoD6RUxQXehV5dHo3mehXfvCtnqlwqQ4y3LTD G/GpPqm8nFGo+OZM6mo7ly4SYyfVeMlGi6c0P1EVqF0Xr4TsRY2OPHWBrZDvfi0n8eZd6i5es +IS/sShuOj2vk2Os2lpUfu04Kypcp3SRX7oVu4lFdyL5t+K+wUFTnAm5wEkfoaXnFYRKyvtYi 3zRBzCxhVkQkNrhWQ2et0MEECOi4ubbPp6yxzL5SyPWgNZRUwOJUozLfdGp8dkI0UANYDjZ8y sBX/WkE2IDxUqzcMWav9xT0K1HqvYLS6888KuvtTrDZWtSTf1ztO64YcUbwUoTcr7QW+GD76V VPEupTqkn78UHED/8dISpj0OB99lmC7JRB7YOZYPUnbhvfzQzy5i6qwTyrh/p6+kcmYe5uEN2 B/3Ek5L16mMcykQonnr3oBw6VOW63HuzW7l4x3U843xyRdeK7o9E3MJjyzbeJmVBTI+r6NWZF fNoMOPh++6OC1rJrn/YNSGq5bu83cK8Xi+pvZNKVByqCNPuHnBedDzgLMzB8WRHnVe4wx74gE yasuQPQpcH14jme9jAwVFSLBWO5UrROPXxubeNBbgsjxq7V7qOaPfZKeQ2D4xdAinm7VkfNLX NhL+D9kruoy9cbV9zmSJ+PmEKI3uPIWMGnHYT6RRUu+PeMHgjvx/NTfZ342bSFoxOvwev3w/3 HxUDif4zu6QhmFohT4EJcjS4LuqrlllEIZVJR5B6WuBiX8Orb1uFe7kM2D24hE/OjvqD5z/Gr +MY0c5paNXPthrJrHbW2dIm5Z5+ini7sUTO/mS3sG/c3THkLKDGzVC1z02fPwMm1m900eVp5j r+wXwR9wSI5A0vtLblpCfGkCH8i6SbDaC2MRAWv78= X-Archives-Salt: 64aa4579-58a3-44bc-b023-ed918f55e603 X-Archives-Hash: 8c71bc32463f0c91568a926849f4fd63 This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) --lwrnfQ7Ej7W9XJmwC4l8b0XKYT5rpxAbN Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="r79NpWlRuYLQUFwIH3Qeep5u1um9oVzxS"; protected-headers="v1" From: Michael 'veremitz' Everitt To: gentoo-dev Message-ID: <55b42dc1-cbfd-8fa0-8bfd-433e7c92a21f@veremit.xyz> Subject: RFC: Require full $P not just $PN on stable/keyword commit messages --r79NpWlRuYLQUFwIH3Qeep5u1um9oVzxS Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Language: en-GB Hello, I've noticed a lot of stabilisation commit messages (and a few keywording= ones too) simply state the package atom and not the relevant release/version. I find this a little meaningless, as unless this is the first time the package has ever been either stabilised or keyworded, it i= s reasonable to expect that there is/was some transition point for a packag= e from when it first entered the Gentoo Repository. Therefore, it would be much /more/ useful to have the package-version tagged in the commit message, so that you could easily grep logs for when= a given version of a package was stabilised, and/or keyworded. Granted, thi= s is more of-use in a historical context compared to a present (future?!) one, but I would argue that it conveys more meaning -with- the version th= an without. Thoughts from outside peanut gallery? Michael / veremitz. --r79NpWlRuYLQUFwIH3Qeep5u1um9oVzxS-- --lwrnfQ7Ej7W9XJmwC4l8b0XKYT5rpxAbN Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" Content-Description: OpenPGP digital signature Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="signature.asc" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJdvI6qAAoJEEwwM0+TwiNxGH4P/i7oIJ9punJDfRGavXwx3yyh JP6oLDRI5LHm9uvuLQ8xs7OmPfYD+1NezYtc2De2wLEsN56xwocFjmUtxvfxUiAC G+9XuKMi2RneKSNWL304ZDj/aiZ3CWDdS+uyRSHQ/ve8XbFekLdXn2ZVvjU71Qf4 hs2nh8yeMk+ncNYkDerdODNWqa8GsH6+bhBm9FoqimWfjCHFaDbSpgCCc8eEgC5y X8XBvIx/X25I8n39k5IpgLyCJ4Ro0ZLV9C3ZxXN5+H3gGF7uIIBzFYcSgu++JY/K ybwxe5KsE+7pR5Oqzxi/zicXszK3W3jWXB4xuNOXFh1gJU5DDdc3Bxs7z98/iVAT SugoHZIZdJnzOJjz3gZEpNakvO5RSvPnVN9tc4mNCcGsWGeO06L+cnXsijT/+Avj gWLbEYOIvErRz5ahSF+oqqz1Fk5I8qsl/wkV27ghF5CCL9R29Bm9aYEGppc/83DR uUQhxThs9GmNhn2BOySwbiz4dzpKm+hvNsIE/WzpdjRd26eZjf2b/243lck+1X3I AQKDiQ1abTNAukgM70KwX4gwXxEeUValUwV49OTEU8mwc5F181YyZHDR/MxIYWwa xLnmlE4Xih+we/jBUQv4zWHLSHuEK2p10fEtXrxuQUUySafXNW0G1X0VRUvXOxZm Ncxa2xjzzXB52gkSgn4Y =SAnc -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --lwrnfQ7Ej7W9XJmwC4l8b0XKYT5rpxAbN--