[gentoo-dev] berlios -> sourceforge move

[gentoo-dev] berlios -> sourceforge move

[Michael Mair-Keimberger]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 10630 bytes --]

Hi all

I'm forwarding you my mail in request of Michał in the hope someone
could find it useful :)

----- Forwarded message from Michael Mair-Keimberger <m.mairkeimberger@gmail.com> -----

From: Michael Mair-Keimberger <m.mairkeimberger@gmail.com>
To: Michał Górny <mgorny@gentoo.org>
Date: Wed, 25 Feb 2015 20:06:35 +0100
Subject: berlios -> sourceforge move

Hello Michał,

Attached is my list about all bugs from the "berlios.de is gone"
tracker (bug #494678) - included with bugs which are already fixed.
Excluded are bugs which are either already removed, or are masked for 
removal.
I've searched for the official homepage for every project, but please
note that i haven't spend to much time on the internet for finding the
correct one.

First of all: a legend of which information is included in this list
* column 1 & 2:	year and month of the last release of given package.
		They are at the beginning so you can easliy sort them
		after year/month with cat $list|sort
* column 3:	O=open bug
		OP=open bug + push request
		FO=fixed by another one then me
		FM=fixed by myself (via PR)
* column 4:	T=this package is marked testing
		ST=this package has stable and testing keywords (more
			than one ebuild
		S=this package is marked stable
		S(x86)=only stable on x86 (not keyworded on amd64)
		S(ppc)=only stable on ppc (not keyworded on amd64)
* column 5:	gentoo bug number
* column 6:	category/package-name
* column 7:	this is my personal ranking about the package status
		based on their last release:
		below 2009: package probably dead
		below 2013: package probalby dead but last release isn't
		_that_ old.
		everything over 2013 is considered active. However, this
		is just my personal reference.
* column 8:	actual homepage of the package. (with some notes
		sometimes)

Next some notes about various packages:

> x11-apps/amlc (bug #537820):
This one was already fixed by Jeroen Roovers, but as i was looking for
it's homepage i think http://zi.fi/amlc/ is the better official hp then
the sourceforge link. There is even a newer version (though it just one
file to compile) which is from 11/2013.

> app-office/rubrica (bug #537708):
This one is really strange. I was looking for it's latest version and
while it seems our version is the last one (2.1.6) i think the _real_
latest version is 2.0.12.
It seems like the project had some version bug because 2.1.6 was created
02/2008 while 2.0.12 is from 10/2012. I haven't looked into it's
changelog but i guess we would need a version bump here.

> net-irc/ngircd (bug #537818)
This bug should be closed. You already pushed my PR a few days ago ;)
BTW, the same is true for bug #516802 - could be closed as well ;)

> media-libs/emfengine (bug #537754)
First though here was: wow - terrible outdated version what we have (0.8
vs. 2.0.3) but than i saw it went commercial. This one probably could be
removed as there are no sources to download - unless you pay for it.

> games-emulation/gngeo (bug #537734)
Long time no release, but since it has source changes from 01/2015 i've
marked it as "active"

> net-misc/qtnx & net-misc/nxcl (bug #537774 & #537778)
Both ebuilds fetch the same source code and my first though was we have
the same package under two different names. I might be wrong here as i
didn't looked into it. However since the last change was 03/2008 i'll
consider it dead and i think they should be removed.

> x11-themes/slim-themes (bug #537814)
I've lied a bit about its change-date. While slim itself has had its last
release 10/2013, slim-themes weren't touch for some longer time. However
since slim itself isn't _that_ dead i decided to mark slim-themes as
active as well (they share the same HP anyway)
BTW, from my open PR's i consider this one pretty sure merge-able,
especially since i still use slim myself (for vm's) ;)

There are also a few package were we are not up-to-date. It's noted next
to the homepage link.
Also please note that i haven't checked for further bugs on bugzilla, so
there might be already open bugs for some of those issues :)

Regards
-- 
greetings
Michael

??		O	T	537688 app-accessibility/festival-ru 	dead		no site found
2005	06	O	S	537690 app-cdr/b5i2iso 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/b5i2iso.berlios/
2004	12	O	T	537692 app-cdr/cuecue 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/cuecue.berlios/
2006	02	O	ST	537694 app-cdr/cuetools 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/cuetools.berlios
2009	08	O	ST	537696 app-cdr/iat 			stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/iat.berlios/
2009	06	O	S	537698 app-crypt/gringotts 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gringotts.berlios/
2010	01	O	T	537702 app-dicts/qvortaro 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/qvortaro.berlios
2002	10	O	S	537704 app-i18n/xsim 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/xsim.berlios/
2011	11	O	S	537706 app-misc/lcd-stuff 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/lcd-stuff.berlios/ (latest version not in tree)
2012	10	O	T	537708 app-office/rubrica 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/rubrica.berlios/ (strange version)
2006	04	O	T	537716 app-text/winefish 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/winefish.berlios/
2010	01	O	T	537718 dev-embedded/usbprog 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/usbprog.berlios
??		O	T	537720 dev-python/iconvcodec 		dead		no site found (maybe https://launchpad.net/python-iconvcodec)
2004	05	O	ST	537722 dev-python/utidylib 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/utidylib.berlios
2013	12	O	T	537726 dev-util/codeblocks 		active		http://www.codeblocks.org/
2013	07	O	S	537730 games-arcade/supertux 		active		http://supertux.lethargik.org/
2005	11	O	S(x86)	537736 games-emulation/gnomeboyadvance 	dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gnomeboyadvance.berlios
2014	12	O	ST	537738 games-puzzle/enigma 		active		http://www.nongnu.org/enigma/
2012	02	O	T	537740 games-server/pvpgn 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/pvpgn.berlios
2009	01	O	S	537742 games-simulation/lincity-ng 	stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/lincity-ng.berlios/
2014	08	O	S(x86)	537744 games-strategy/netpanzer 	active		http://www.netpanzer.info/Download/ (latest version not in tree)
2007	06	O	S	537748 media-gfx/gimmage 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gimmage.berlios
2012	12	O	ST	537750 media-gfx/mirage 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/mirageiv.berlios (latest version not in tree)
2015	02	O	T	537754 media-libs/emfengine 		active		http://soft.proindependent.com/emf/news.html (latest version not in tree - commercial)
2007	05	O	S	537756 media-libs/phat 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/phat.berlios/
2008	08	O	T	537758 media-sound/gbsplay 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gbsplay.berlios/
2014	02	O	ST	537760 media-sound/gimmix 		active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gimmix.berlios/
2007	10	OP	S	537762 media-sound/horgand		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/horgand.berlios/
2008	03	O	S	537774 net-misc/nxcl 			dead 		http://sourceforge.net/projects/freenx.berlios
2008	03	O	S	537778 net-misc/qtnx 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/freenx.berlios - same like nxcl??
2006	02	OP	S	537782 net-p2p/gift-ares 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gift-ares.berlios/
2005	01	OP	S	537784 net-p2p/gift-fasttrack 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gift-fasttrack.berlios
2006	12	OP	T	537786 net-wireless/bcm43xx-fwcutter 	dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/bcm43xx.berlios/
2009	12	O	ST	537788 net-wireless/python-wifi 	stale		https://pypi.python.org/pypi/python-wifi/0.5.0
2015	02	O	ST	537790 sci-geosciences/gpsd 		active		https://savannah.nongnu.org/projects/gpsd/
2011	08	O	ST	537792 sci-libs/liborigin 		stale		http://soft.proindependent.com/liborigin2/
2011	09	O	ST	537796 sci-mathematics/snns		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/snns/ 
??		O	T(ppc)	537802 sys-apps/lsadb 			dead		no site found
2013	10	OP	S	537814 x11-themes/slim-themes 		active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/slim.berlios/
2014	11	O	T	537818 net-irc/ngircd 			active		http://ngircd.barton.de/news.php.en (already fixed)
??		O	S	537824 app-benchmarks/spew 		dead		no site found
2011	12	FO	T	537700 app-crypt/tpm-emulator 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/tpm-emulator.berlios
2014	12	FO	S	537710 app-portage/eix			active		https://github.com/vaeth/eix
2014	03	FO	T	537714 app-text/u2ps/u2ps 		active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/u2ps.berlios/
2010	11	FO	S	537724 dev-tex/qtexengine 		stale		http://soft.proindependent.com/qtexengine/
2007	09	FO	S	537732 games-emulation/dboxfe 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/dboxfe.berlios/
2012	01	FO	ST	537734 games-emulation/gngeo 		active		http://code.google.com/p/gngeo/ (long time no release, but changes from 01/2015)
2008	02	FO	T	537746 kde-misc/kio-ftps 		dead		http://kde-apps.org/content/show.php/kio-ftps?content=35875
2011	06	FO	S	537752 media-gfx/splashutils 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/fbsplash.berlios
2011	12	FO	S	537764 media-video/griffith 		stale		https://launchpad.net/griffith/
2007	09	FO	S	537766 media-video/ttcut 		dead		http://www.tritime.de/topics/ttcut/
2004	02	FO	T	537768 net-analyzer/nast 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/nast.berlios/
2007	07	FO	S	537770 net-dialup/radiusclient-ng 	dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/radiusclient-ng.berlios
2013	04	FM	S	537772 net-mail/fetchmail 		active		http://www.fetchmail.info/
2008	04	FM	T	537776 net-misc/nxsadmin 		dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/nxsadmin.berlios
2006	01	FO	T	537780 net-misc/sipsak 			dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/sipsak.berlios
2015	02	FO	T	537794 sci-libs/pycifrw 		active		https://pypi.python.org/pypi/PyCifRW/
2010	11	FM	S	537798 sys-apps/gscanbus 		stale		http://sourceforge.net/projects/gscanbus.berlios/
2012	08	FM	S	537800 sys-apps/gsmartcontrol 		stale		http://gsmartcontrol.sourceforge.net/home/
2011	03	FM	ST	537804 sys-apps/rename 			stale		http://rename.sourceforge.net/ (latest version not in tree)
2014	09	FO	S	537808 sys-fs/ext4magic 		active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/ext4magic
2014	08	FM	S	537810 x11-libs/tslib 			active		https://github.com/kergoth/tslib/ (latest version not in tree)
2006	09	FM	S	537812 x11-themes/gtk-engines-candido 	dead		http://sourceforge.net/projects/candido.berlios/
2014	05	FM	S	537816 app-arch/star 			active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/s-tar
2013	11	FO	S	537820 x11-apps/amlc 			active		http://sourceforge.net/projects/amlc.berlios/ (shoulb be changed to http://zi.fi/amlc/)




----- End forwarded message -----

-- 
greetings
Michael Mair-Keimberger

[-- Attachment #2: Digital signature --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 819 bytes --]

Re: [gentoo-dev] berlios -> sourceforge move

[Bernard Cafarelli]

Le 26/02/2015 17:08, Michael Mair-Keimberger a écrit :
>> net-misc/qtnx & net-misc/nxcl (bug #537774 & #537778)
> Both ebuilds fetch the same source code and my first though was we have
> the same package under two different names. I might be wrong here as i
> didn't looked into it. However since the last change was 03/2008 i'll
> consider it dead and i think they should be removed.
Same source tarball, but different ${S} (and different build system) :)
nxcl was intended as a generic library, but only qtnx was built on top 
of it

As for qtnx, it is the only open-source client in-tree for "old" NX 
servers, and still does its job.
But if we drop packages according to last upstream release, most of the 
"old" NX packages should be treecleaned too as they have dead upstreams 
since 2011 (best case):
net-misc/neatx (server, 2010)
net-misc/nxcl (client lib, 2008)
net-misc/{nxclient-3*,nxnode,nxserver-freeedition} (proprietary, 2011)
net-misc/nxsadmin (server admin tool, 2008)
net-misc/nxserver-freenx (server, 2009)
net-misc/qtnx (client, 2008)

and

app-admin/eselect-nxserver (not used in x2go)

The active replacement (though not drop-in) is x2go for an open-source 
setup, and NX 4 for proprietary (not in tree, bug #488334)

-- 
Bernard Cafarelli (Voyageur)
Gentoo developer (NX, GNUstep, net-misc, llvm/clang, ...)